The French National Academy of Medicine leans towards the theory that the Covid-19 virus originated from a laboratory, according to a report published on Wednesday.
While the hypothesis of natural transmission is backed by genetic samples found in Wuhan’s market suggesting small carnivorous animals like raccoon dogs may have served as intermediaries between bats and humans, this new report does not find it equally convincing.
Key Points on Lab Theory
- Unique elements in SARS-CoV-2: The virus shows unique features not seen in other natural coronaviruses, potentially enhancing its transmissibility, as highlighted by proponents of the lab theory.
- Academy’s stance: The Academy acknowledges a set of facts and arguments supporting the lab leak hypothesis, although it does not explicitly endorse this theory.
The report from the French National Academy of Medicine emphasizes that there are no definitive elements favoring the natural transmission hypothesis. Moreover, the recommendations lean more towards improved laboratory oversight than tracking pathogens in animals.
Reactions to the Report
Divided Opinions: The report has drawn strong criticism from French scientists favoring the natural origin theory, like researcher Florence Débarre. She described it as “scientifically deficient” and “unworthy of the institution publishing it.”
However, virologist Christine Rouzioux acknowledged there might be “more arguments” for the lab hypothesis, though she emphasized that this should not be interpreted as a definitive stance.
